Aston Villa’s window of opportunity for Geny Catamo casts doubt on Emi Buendia’s future

Emi Buendia still faces an uphill battle of consistently getting into Aston Villa’s starting line-ups.

Unai Emery has turned things around for Villa and has the Villans as high as third in the Premier League.

The Spaniard has chopped and changed his starting eleven on multiple occasions this season, handing game time to fringe players in the Europa League and cup competitions.

Buendia has enjoyed a return to form this season after overcoming injury setbacks on B6, but the Argentine is still struggling to cement his place in Emery’s starting line-ups, despite positive performances.

Aston Villa‘s tracking of Sporting CP’s Geny Catamo only adds to the uncertainty around Buendia‘s future at Villa Park.

Emi Buendia's league starts for Aston Villa.
Credit: Imago/Breaking Media

Aston Villa can sign Geny Catamo for £17m in 2026

NSWE are aware of financial constraints, and if the Villans want to spend money in the future, sales may need to be sanctioned.

Emery has a list of players whom he could sell this month, as Aston Villa are now in the process of narrowing down potential incomings.

However, the Villans may have a long-term plan to sign Catamo.

As reported by Portuguese outlet A Bola, there is a high chance that Catamo will leave Sporting CP in 2026 for £17.3million due to a stalemate over a contract renewal.

They have suggested that Aston Villa were interested in the winger last summer, and may be one of the clubs that come back in for the 24-year-old this year.

However, there’s no reason why Villa couldn’t test the waters with an offer this window, especially given the current issues over a contract agreement.

Catamo can play on either wing and could be a direct replacement for Buendia.

Emi Buendia vs Catamo stats comparison

Buendia possesses high-quality shooting ability and has the skill to flip a game on its head.

Emery has used the attacker off the bench in multiple games. Bunedia’s goal in his three-minute cameo against Arsenal back in December showed the forward’s importance, scoring the winning goal for Villa.

However, Catamo has other qualities that Buendia can’t give Emery.

PlayerDribbles per 90Shots on target per 90
Emi Buendia0.590.47
Geny Catamo2.051.16
Buendia vs Catamo stats (league comparisons from this season)

As highlighted, Catamo’s main advantage over Buendia is his ability to take a man on successfully, but the right-winger also has a better conversion rate in terms of hitting the target.

It’s one transfer story to keep an eye on, as Villa’s interest in a new forward this month is well and truly prevalent.

Stay up to date this winter with our Aston Villa transfer tracker. Click to see every done deal at Villa Park, plus expert reaction from our team of writers.